Elegant Georgian dining room with ivory paneling, a walnut dining table and tall windows overlooking a golden autumn garden.

Windsor Farms Asking Prices and Where 2026 Sales Landed

  • November 19, 2026

In May, a brick-and-slate colonial at 6 Berkshire Road in Windsor Farms was listed at $3.19 million. Richmond BizSense reported that it went under contract all-cash just over two weeks later and closed July 1 at $4.02 million, which was more than $800,000 over its asking price. Eight months earlier, a 1934 house beside the Country Club of Virginia's Westhampton course was listed at $2.6 million. According to BizSense, the price was cut to $2.34 million in November and the house closed January 5 at $2.22 million.

Both houses were in the same part of the city and the same price range, and both sold within the same year. Of the two, the cheaper listing had the higher sale price. Every Windsor Farms and Near West End city sale in 2026 with a published asking price followed that pattern. Houses listed low sold over asking within weeks. Houses listed high stayed on the market, had price cuts and closed below their first asking price. For a buyer comparing Windsor Farms with the neighborhoods around it, the gap between an asking price and recent nearby closings is the best clue to which way a sale will go.

The Citywide Number Hides the Spread

The Central Virginia Regional MLS reports that single-family sellers in Richmond city got 99.1% of their original list price in October 2026 and 100.3% for the year through October. October's median sale price was $444,000, median days on market was 23, and there were 346 homes for sale, about 1.9 months of supply. In a typical Richmond sale, the asking price and the sale price end up almost the same.

Near West End sales above $2 million have not worked that way this year. Six closings in 2026 had both an asking price and a sale price reported in Richmond BizSense, which rounds up the region's five priciest home sales each month using MLS data. Those six ranged from about 85% of the original asking price to about 126%. Each one landed above or below asking. None came close to the citywide 99%.

Address Neighborhood Original asking Sold Sale vs. original asking
6 Berkshire Road Windsor Farms $3.19M, May 28 $4.02M, July 1 about 126%
3905 Sulgrave Road Windsor Farms $2.8M, May 21 $3.1M, June 30 about 111%
104 E. Hillcrest Ave. Hillcrest $3.59M, April $3.5M, Aug. 3 about 97%
Hill Crest, 5103 Cary Street Road Hillcrest $10M, May $9.1M, Aug. 17 about 91%
701 Old Locke Lane West End $4M, May $3.6M, Sept. 10 90%
6134 Saint Andrews Circle Beside CCV Westhampton course $2.6M, Oct. 2025 $2.22M, Jan. 5 about 85%

The table covers top-five closings with published asking prices. It is not a complete record of Windsor Farms sales. Still, the pattern in it is consistent, and it matches how pricing works in a thin market.

Why Underpricing Paid Off on Berkshire and Sulgrave

The Berkshire Road house was a 6,200-square-foot colonial built in 1950 on a half-acre lot. It had been renovated and expanded, with a renovation designed by Dan Ensminger and an addition built by Hampden Hill Custom Building. The listing included bluestone patios, a freestanding stone fireplace, a garden house and a two-car garage. It was listed at $3.19 million, and the all-cash buyer paid $4.02 million. The City of Richmond had assessed the property at $2.38 million, so the sale price was roughly 169% of the assessment.

The 3905 Sulgrave Road sale, also covered in Richmond BizSense, followed the same pattern on a smaller scale. The 5,800-square-foot, four-bedroom house was listed May 21 at $2.8 million and closed June 30 at $3.1 million. The same house sold in April 2021 for $1.7 million. Both Windsor Farms houses went on the market in late May, and both sold above asking within about six weeks.

What Happened to the Houses Priced High

The houses that sold below asking were not weak properties. The Hill Crest mansion at 5103 Cary Street Road sold for $9.1 million on August 17, the highest residential price in Richmond city's history. It beat the $9 million sale of 5407 Cary Street Road in 2024. It still sold about $900,000 below its $10 million May asking price, in an all-cash purchase by an LLC with no buyer's agent.

Around the corner, 104 E. Hillcrest Ave. is a 7,300-square-foot house that had been fully renovated, including new exterior glass, interior glass-and-metal doors brought over from Europe, and a new façade. Its listing agent told Richmond BizSense that the house received multiple offers. It sold August 3 for $3.5 million, slightly below its April asking price of $3.59 million. Even with several offers, the price stayed below asking. The house had been listed at about the level buyers would pay, while the Windsor Farms houses had been listed below it.

701 Old Locke Lane, a 9,300-square-foot Tudor Revival on about an acre in the city's West End, took longer. BizSense reported that it was listed at $4 million in May and cut to $3.8 million in June. It went under contract July 4 and closed September 10 at $3.6 million. The Saint Andrews Circle house went through the same steps over the fall and winter of 2025: a price cut in November, a contract about a week later, and a closing at $2.22 million against a city assessment of $2 million. Its sale price was about 111% of its assessment. Berkshire's was about 169%.

Both houses sold above their city assessments. The difference between them was where each started. Saint Andrews started above where it closed, and Berkshire started well below where it closed.

Where the Fall Sales Leave a Buyer

The most recent closings in the Near West End's city neighborhoods were also among the region's priciest. 335 Clovelly Road, a 4,100-square-foot house in Windsor Farms, sold September 18 for $2.7 million. In October, 4912 Lockgreen Circle sold for $2.8 million and 1 Greenway Lane in Hampton Gardens sold for $2.6 million, both in the region's top five for the month, according to BizSense's October roundup. In September, the buyers of 701 Old Locke Lane were also the sellers of 15 Roslyn Road in Hampton Gardens, which sold for $2.5 million that month. That household moved within the Near West End.

Those closings give a buyer a recent range. Within a few months, four Windsor Farms, Lockgreen and Hampton Gardens houses of roughly 4,000 square feet or more sold between $2.5 million and $2.8 million. Earlier in the year, 213 Gun Club Road in Windsor Farms sold for $2.1 million in January, and 403 Harlan Circle in Hampton Gardens sold for $2.6 million in June. In 2025, 3812 Dover Road sold off-market for $3.2 million in August as the region's top sale that month. Its seller had paid $1.65 million in 2020.

For a buyer, this means the asking price is the first thing to check against recent closings on nearby streets. In 2026, Windsor Farms listings priced below those closings, Berkshire and Sulgrave, sold well above asking. A listing priced well above those closings may come down over time. Old Locke Lane went from first listing to contract in about two months, and Saint Andrews Circle took several months and a price cut. In both cases the buyer paid less than the seller first asked. Our due diligence guide for Windsor Farms covers what to check about a house once you are under contract.

Questions Buyers Ask About These Sales

Does a Windsor Farms listing priced under recent sales mean a bargain?

Not on the 2026 record. Both Windsor Farms listings priced under the market closed above asking, by about $300,000 on Sulgrave Road and more than $800,000 on Berkshire Road, and Berkshire went to an all-cash buyer. In both cases, the buyer's final price was set well above the listing.

How useful is the city assessment for judging a price here?

It is a weak guide for this tier. The 2026 sales with published assessments closed at about 111% and 169% of their city assessed values. Recent closings on nearby streets give a buyer a better comparison.

Is the Near West End's top tier moving like the rest of Richmond?

The citywide median sale price for single-family homes was flat for the year through October 2026, at $430,000 in both 2025 and 2026, and sellers got about full asking price on average. Near West End sales above $2 million showed a much wider range against asking, from about 85% to about 126%, and how each house was priced decided where it landed.

Windsor Farms houses are rarely for sale, and this year an asking price there affected the final price by hundreds of thousands of dollars. Chris Small has worked in Richmond's historic neighborhoods since the early 1980s, and Chris Small Group can show you how each recent Windsor Farms and Near West End closing was priced and how it sold before you make your own offer. Schedule a Private Consultation.

Work With Us

We pride ourselves in providing personalized solutions that bring our clients closer to their dream properties and enhance their long-term wealth. Contact us today to find out how we can be of assistance to you!

Follow Us on Instagram